I have finally gotten away from all of the advice given to writers about craft, publishing, and marketing. Yes, all of that has its place. There is a time to go into those things, but I found that too much of it has stifled my creativity. I needed to detox from it and get back to the pleasure of simply enjoying fiction again. We’re all different, and some authors may find their creativity flourishing when immersed with writing community advice. I am not one of them, apparently. I was surprised to learn that after spending two full months just listening to fiction for fun that my creativity flourished.
For the record, in this blog post, I am talking about traditionally published books. I have trouble finding indie audiobooks that I’m interested in, and while I was using my Kindle to listen to ebooks, I ended up with really bad headaches. My Kindle is an older model. AI voices have gotten better since that Kindle came out. I’m sure the current Kindles being sold would not give me headaches, but I don’t want to buy another Kindle when I have two already. So I signed up for the Libby app from my library and have been using that to listen to audiobooks on my iPhone. Hence the traditionally published content I’ve been consuming after years of only reading indie stuff.
Once in a while an indie author will think I’m talking about their book and email me about it. This is not the case in this post.
That all said, I did gather some thoughts along the way of reading what publishers are okay with, and I thought I’d share them in this post. The cat pic is here just because I love cat pics. 🙂
General Thoughts on Writing
Tension is not supposed to be on every page.
There is one particular trad author I am thinking of on this point. I have actually enjoyed two of her books I’ve listened to so far. I plan to listen to her others, but I need a break from her at the moment. The genre is YA fantasy horror. Given that it’s horror, there’s tension. Overall, she does a great job of building a gothic kind of atmosphere, but there is so much intense dread the main character is feeling all the time that I don’t have a chance to calm down from any of it. Okay, the tension is not literally on every single page, but it’s definitely there a couple of times per chapter. These are like jump scares they throw into scary movies. One is around every corner. Even with the “dum dum!” high-pitch music, you no longer jump. You get desensitized to it. That makes those moments lose their effectiveness. Yesterday when I was listening to her book, I found myself rolling my eyes and thinking, “Someone better be dead this time.” About 80% of the time, nothing is actually happening. It’s false alarm stuff. When the moment delivers, it’s great. When it doesn’t, it’s obnoxious. The author would be better off just dwelling on the subtle feeling of dread for at least half of these “OH NO!” moments. Take things down to a “huh…that’s kind of weird” notch instead. Don’t underestimate the power of being subtle. The subtle stuff is often far more tension-inducing than the quick scares.
To give a romance equivalent, I remember years and years ago when I read a lot of romances. Almost every other page would be the characters’ needs and urges to be with the object of their affection. I don’t think I got through many scenes where a hero didn’t have an erection or the heroine wasn’t getting wet or feeling all tingly down there. It took me out of the romance story completely. I mean, sure, those things are a part of attraction, but people don’t always walk around erect/wet/tingling (and if they did, they should be seeing a doctor). It’s possible to have a conversation with someone without all of those physical urges getting in the way, and you can also kiss a person without wanting to rip their clothes off. And if it’s not the physical stuff in a romance that gets annoying, it’s all the “does he/she or doesn’t he/she love me?” angst thrown at us. Most of the time, that angst stems from the fact that no one is saying what is really on their minds. They’re too busy assuming things about the other person. That whole setup gets old fast, and I stopped reading romance because of it.
So as a writer, I’m thinking that it’s best to be more low-key on the tension, whatever that tension is. Yes, have tension, but have it when it matters to the plot and/or character development. Give your readers some downtime to simply be in the story. Think of tension like your favorite dinner. You don’t want to keep cramming food down your throat. You want to consume the food slowly. That way you don’t get full too fast and end up with a stomach ache, AND you get the pleasure of enjoying each and every flavorful moment of the meal. Those low-key moments help to give your reader time to have some calm before the next tense moment.
Now on the flip side…
Events that Don’t Matter Should Be Removed
I end up not finishing about 70% of the books I start because of things happening that don’t matter to the story. (Hence why I signed up for the library app. I got tired of throwing money away.)
There’s this one book that’s a science fiction horror novel. It started off great. These characters were supposed to partake in an experiment. The setup was awesome. I was on the edge of my seat and listening to every word. Then after chapter four, I realized that the events that were happening in this experiment led to nothing. Chapters 4-10 were pretty much all the same. Just different monsters in different places. It was like the characters were just running in circles. You could have removed those events and still had the story. The author probably thought all of the graphic and horrific events she threw in there were riveting, but they got boring fast. It would have been better if this author had just went through one event and gave the final punchline, which was “there is a psychopath somewhere among you”. I cheated and listened to the last chapter to see what the point of the whole book was, and that was it. And then I realized there was a Book 2. As soon as I saw it was a series, I said, “Nope,” and took the author off my tag list.
Another book I read was a book that bordered on general thriller and horror. Overall, it was funny in places, and that is the only thing that kept me listening, but I could put the book down with it playing, come back to it, and not really miss anything. The author is a well-known author who’s won awards. Like, he’s been in bookstores and stuff, you know. So you expect better. I thought this one book was a fluke, so I listened to another one. This was a supernatural dark horror, and that one was so ridiculously repetitive that I was gritting my teeth toward the end. I wanted to know what was causing all the scary events in the town. So I held out, but it was not easy, and I ended up switching to other books to get a break. I wonder if the publisher told that authors that he had to write so many words in order to be published, so he put in a lot of filler into his stories. I borrowed a movie based off of one of his books at the library, and even that one lagged. I want to like this author, but one more book like that, and I think I’m done. I mean, he does have some good ideas. I just wish he’d tighten things up. Like throw out at least 25% of his stories.
Let me give you a real-life example of what those books are like so you get a better idea of what I’m talking about. Let’s say I’m telling you about the time I bought a car. I start the story off by saying I left the house to go to the dealership. Then I say I went to the office store and picked up some paper. When I was done, I made it halfway to the car dealership. But then I realize I needed some paper towels and bananas, so I stopped to get those from the grocery store. After that, I finally got to the car dealership. Right away, I decided instead of looking at cars, I see this random customer (that has nothing to do with anything) and talk about their hair and clothes. Then I talk to a salesperson who’s been gravitating toward me the entire time I fixated on that other customer. I proceeded to look at a couple of cars and take them for a test drive. Finally, you think, we’re getting somewhere. But no, we’re not because for whatever reason, I feel the need to tell you about some random event that happened to my kid last week at school and how I felt about it. (This event had nothing to do with cars, by the way, though I do toss in that the principal has a red one.) After that, I picked a car and sat down to work on the payment plan, like whether I’ll make payments, lease, or buy the thing outright. And just when I got to the part where I made my decision and could proceed to the financial person, I figured I’d stop by a vending machine and compare the snacks because I’ve been at the dealership for half the day (since nothing ever goes fast at a car dealership). By the time I get the key and leave the lot, I doubt anyone gives a crap that I ever bought a car.
That is what those “event” stories are like to me, and it’s why I do not finish them or I will walk away and leave the them playing in hopes they’ll pick up somewhere.
We need to see a line of progression from Point A to Point B to Point C, etc. It needs to go on an upward slope. That slope needs to end at the climax. Sending characters on these wild goose chases are a waste of time.
***
That’s all I got for today. All of these books have been making me think of ways I can make my own better. Yes, there is a lot of advice out there for writers, but some of the best things we can pick up in storytelling is by reading stories for pleasure.





