Money Management: How Do You Want to Pay Off Debt?

I’m in the middle of paying off debt. I’ve been married now for 18.5 years, and, unfortunately, debt is still a way of life around my house.  I had the head knowledge of why being debt free was a good idea, but the heart wasn’t interested in doing what my mind wanted. It’s only been in the past year that I finally got serious about being debt free. Today I wanted to make a blog post addressing the payment of debts.

debt reduction

ID 53230815 © Jehsomwang | Dreamstime.com

Here are the two main strategies of paying off debt that seem to be the most popular:

1. Smallest to Largest:

This is mostly known as the Dave Ramsey way (aka the snowball method). For anyone who hasn’t heard of it, it involves saving $1000 in an emergency fund. Then you look at all of your debts, from smallest to largest. You pay off as much as you can on the smallest debt while paying minimum payments on the other debt. Then when the smallest is out of the way, you apply that amount to the new smallest debt on the list.

2. Highest Interest to Lowest Interest:

Then there’s the Suze Orman method. Other people since have mentioned it, but she’s the first one who introduced me to the concept, so I’m giving her credit for it. In this one, you pay off the debt with the highest interest rate first while making minimum payments off the others. When you knock out that specific debt, you tackle the debt with the next highest interest rate.

I’ve tried both of these over the years, and neither worked for my personality. I discovered I’m not motivated by either method.

In my last post, I talked about not taking advice from other people, and I think this is an area where this fits. Just because some people are motivated by the Dave Ramsey or Suze Orman method of paying off debt, it doesn’t mean all of us are.

When you are looking for a strategy that best fits your life, here are some things to consider:

1. How much of a financial risk can you afford to take?

The question that often pops up is, “Should we save first or pay off debt first?”

In my opinion: it depends on your situation. I know this isn’t helpful on the surface, but let me explain my reason for this answer.

I think we need to use the method that is tailored specifically for us and our comfort levels. Some people may not be comfortable with a $1000 emergency fund. They may want one that is $5000. Some people may even want more than that.

If you’re an author who is living off of your writing income, you’re self-employed. If you have no one to help pay the bills, you may want to have at least 3-6 months of living expenses in your savings account before taking care of debt. By the way, most self-employed people take on a much higher risk in general because if they don’t sell their product, they don’t get paid. On the other hand, people who work for someone else will get the paycheck as long as they don’t get fired.

Also, whether or not you live alone plays a factor into the level of risk you have. If you’re living alone, you are responsible for all of your financial bills. Or, if you aren’t living alone, you might be the only one bringing home any money. That puts additional pressure on you to make sure you can provide for everyone. If you have a spouse who is bringing in money, then you have some buffer in case you can’t make enough money to pay your bills anymore. In my opinion, the more sources of income you have coming into your home, the better off you are. So if you have multiple sources of income, you can afford to have a lower savings amount before you start paying off the debt.

So consider how much you want to risk before starting off with paying off debt (or continuing to pay off debt if you’re in the middle of doing this already).

2. What motivates you the most?

I think motivation is more important than anything else when it comes to paying off debt. If our hearts aren’t in it, then it’s going to be hard to commit.

If watching your debt list quickly grow smaller because you’re paying off the smallest ones first “wows” you, then you would probably like the Dave Ramsey plan. If you like knowing you’re getting rid of the highest interest rates, then you’ll probably like Suze Orman’s plan.

I actually fall into neither camp. I hate both of those plans. They never motivated me. I found out that I’m more motivated by knocking out the debt that takes out the biggest chunk of my income every month. The more cash flow I have each month, the easier it is for me to relax. I have discovered that I’m best motivated when I focus on paying off the debt that takes out the biggest chunk of my household income every month.

For example, years ago I had a truck payment that was $726 a month. That is insane! (We never paid off cars and kept trading them in on others, so a lot of our car debt just rolled into the new loan. Do NOT do this. I know I said don’t take advice, but seriously, this is a trap and it will bite you in the end.) I had about five credit cards, and another car loan  at the time. My husband was active duty military, and we were barely getting by because his income kept going into all of the debt. I had been trying to get through the Dave Ramsey plan, and I just couldn’t get into it because I was taking care of the smallest debt first. I realized if I paid off the truck, I would have $726 a month to buy good quality groceries with. Whereas if I only paid off the smallest debt, I’d only free my cash flow by $50. I was tired of peanut butter, ramen noodles, and other cheap stuff for me and my family. I wanted to eat well. So that’s what I did. And I didn’t roll the $726 into other debt. I used it for food. When you have six people in a family, food is a huge part of the monthly budget.

So, this is what I’ve been ever since. I’ve been paying off the debt that takes out the largest chunk of my household monthly budget first. I don’t know if anyone ever came up with my particular method, but I discovered this on my own after trial and error.

My point to all of the rambling is this:

If you find a way to pay off debt that excites you, you’re much better off than following someone else’s strategy. Don’t be afraid to try different techniques. Don’t be afraid if you end up failing while trying one strategy. It just means that strategy didn’t fit your personality. Don’t feel guilty just because someone else could do it a particular way and you can’t. I think we beat ourselves up too much over this kind of thing. Person A’s debt strategy plan was a good fit for Person A. It might not be a good fit for you. We don’t have to pigeon hole ourselves into someone else’s box. We are free to explore other ideas. As long as you’re paying off debt, that’s what matters, right?

What are your thoughts? Is there a different way you’re paying off debt that I didn’t mention?

About Ruth Ann Nordin

Ruth Ann Nordin mainly writes historical western romances and Regencies. From time to time, she branches out to contemporaries romances and other genres (such as science fiction thrillers). For more information, please go to www.ruthannnordin.com or check out https://ruthannnordinauthorblog.wordpress.com.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Money Management: How Do You Want to Pay Off Debt?

  1. I like the Dave Ramsey way because when you pay off the smallest debt (it doesn’t take as long) you feel a sense of accomplishment. And you owe to fewer companies. I love the Dave Ramsey plan because he’s been teaching people for years, and so many people are now debt free because of him. If I had started in my 30s instead of waiting until my 50s, I would be debt free except for my mortgage. But, like you said, some people just aren’t motivated to do it Dave’s way. And that’s okay. He’s not the grand master of finance. (Well, he kind of is, LOL.)

    The important thing is that you’re trying to pay off debt, no matter what method you use. You have to do what keeps you motivated. My motivation goes back and forth, so it’s time for me to watch Financial Peace University again. 🙂

    • I know you love Dave Ramsey. I was thinking of you the entire time I was writing about him. LOL

      It took me years of putting the other debt on hold, but I did pay off the house. It was my largest payment every month, and I figured if I were to lose anything, I would rather lose the car than my house. Now I have two more debts left. It didn’t help that we kept on getting cars when we didn’t have the cash for it. We also had a furnace break down in the middle of winter and had to put the new one on the credit card. I am determined that I will never get another loan again unless it’s a life or death issue. *knock on wood nothing serious is going to happen*

      I’m in my 40s now, so I wasted a lot of time, too. Don’t feel too bad. You’re not the only one who put this whole thing off. 🙂

  2. I paid off my college debt earlier this year, but not because of any major strategy or anything. Instead, I used my inheritance from my grandfather to wipe out what was left over. Up until then, I was paying two-hundred bucks a month every month, with the understanding my debt would be gone n ten years. Wiping out my debt in one fell swoop and still having a little left over was a welcome experience, especially since it helped when it became time to get a car (speaking of which, does having a payment plan for it count as debt? I don’t think it does, but some may disagree).
    Hopefully I won’t have any more debt beyond paying credit card bills for a while. If I do take on debt again someday, I’d prefer it to be for something important, like a house. But that’s still a ways away from where I am now.

    • That’s a smart use of the inheritance. Student loans are a real headache.

      Did you get a car loan or are you leasing it? I guess I wouldn’t consider a lease debt since you’re going to return it. What you’re really doing is renting the car. As for a car loan, that would be debt. At your age and considering you knocked the student debt out of the way, a car loan isn’t a bad thing. I would just make sure you hold onto the car for a few years after paying off the loan. My husband and I weren’t smart enough to do that, and that is how we got into trouble with car debt.

      I don’t know if debt can be completely avoided. I mean, I’m sure it can be by someone out there, but when you’re starting out, there are so many expenses that come up, and you’re not making much at that age. If you’re going to survive, you have to make sure you have the things you need. The good news is, income should go up as you get more work experience under your belt.

      • I bought the car, I’m just paying for it in increments rather than all at once. I get to keep it without further payments after five years, I think.

        • You have a car loan. The lease would mean you make payments each month to rent the car and then return it after the term of the lease is up, which is usually two years. In your case, you’re still making payments, but you’ll own the car at the end of five years or sooner (if you pay it off early).

          Personally, I prefer a car loan because at least you have something you will own when you’re done making payments. I had an uncle who always leased cars. He didn’t like driving anything that was older than two or three years.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.